Grand Theft Auto, AI Jesus, and Who Gets to Make the Rules
Imagine buying Grand Theft Auto for the thrill of getting away with things and then spending the evening painting an apartment. Rabbi Dave wonders whether that would count as a good deed. Friar Rod figures it would depend on what you were neglecting at home while you did it. Neither man has played Grand Theft Auto VI, a fact they disclose up front on What The Frock? and then proceed to get an hour’s worth of conversation out of anyway.
There’s a real question underneath the joke. Part of the appeal of a game like Grand Theft Auto is getting to try things you’d never do in real life. But even in a world built for breaking rules, somebody decides what you can do. The developers make those choices inside the game. California tried to make one outside it, restricting the sale or rental of certain violent games to minors. The Supreme Court struck down the law in 2011, and the discussion takes an especially What The Frock? turn when Dave gets to what happened to Leland Yee, the lawmaker who championed it. As Dave puts it, Yee’s own story could have been a Grand Theft Auto plot.
The next detour begins with the U.S. Catholic bishops’ interest in AI ethics and ends up somewhere more personal. What happens when people turn to an AI Jesus or an AI rabbi with a problem they might once have brought to a member of the clergy? Rod remembers a time when he gave a woman blunt advice and his superior told him he should have offered comfort. It’s a revealing story because both men had heard the same account and understood the job of a pastor differently. A chatbot can produce a reassuring answer in seconds. Deciding whether reassurance is what someone needs takes judgment, and people with years of experience can still disagree.
By the time Dave and Rod get to Gavin Newsom and California’s death row, the consequences of that judgment are considerably higher. They revisit an earlier conversation about commutations and ask how far a governor’s authority extends. Then Rod raises the possibility of a sincere profession of faith in the final moments of a condemned person’s life, and Dave wants to know what that means for someone who spent a lifetime trying to live by that same faith. It’s the kind of disagreement worth hearing them work through, especially if you tuned in expecting two guys to argue about a video game.
Listen to the full episode of What The Frock? to hear how they get from Grand Theft Carriage to the question of what anyone is owed on their last day. Dave, for his part, still has better things to spend seventy dollars on.







Leave a Reply